Current:Home > NewsYou're overthinking it — how speculating can spoil a TV show -CapitalWay
You're overthinking it — how speculating can spoil a TV show
View
Date:2025-04-12 05:59:21
Kids, gather 'round ol' Pappy Glen's knee, and he'll tell you a tale of television in the olden days of his far-off youth. It was a time when your basic TV show was just that: basic. It didn't demand much from you, it just unspooled itself before your eyes. Sitcoms could be counted upon to supply canned laughter (the com) but their setting, characters and premise (the sit) would reset back to starting positions every week. Characters on cop shows, doctor shows, lawyer shows and nighttime soaps might get run through serialized plots over the course of a given season ("Who shot J.R.?"), but they certainly didn't permanently grow or deepen or complicate; that wasn't why people watched.
Mostly, what TV provided was familiarity, comfort, pattern recognition. You might ask a friend or co-worker if they'd seen last night's Hill Street Blues, and you might idly speculate about that shocking death on ER, but the remarkable thing about such speculation was just how idle it inevitably was.
When the internet came along, that passive involvement grew active. Fandoms swelled to fill message boards and chatrooms with a more fervent species of discussion and speculation. TV changed to account for this. The X-Files' overarching serialized plotting grew hilariously dense and complicated (whose side were those alien bounty hunters on, again?), because suddenly it had leave to do so. Hardcore fans were only too happy to publish their own painstakingly researched roadmaps unpacking a show's dense lore on their webpages. Series like Lost and, most recently, Westworld were made to withstand, and benefit from, that kind of close attention.
But this kind of analysis was only ever meant for a very specific type of high-concept, puzzle-box series like The X-Files, Lost, Westworld, Fringe and Dark – shows intentionally packed with secrets and hidden connections for viewers to untangle. But to hop onto social media is to see this same tool of inquiry applied unilaterally, every damn where, to shows that hide no secrets, that withhold no information for only the most eagle-eyed viewers to discover.
I'm not talking about plumbing subtext, here, which is always fair game. I'm talking about looking for hidden, intentionally inserted meanings where none exist. Shows like Succession, House of the Dragon, Better Call Saul and The Mandalorian now come in for the kind of speculation that can't help but outpace their writers rooms. A character's absence from a given episode is taken as proof of their death, when it turns out the actor just booked another gig, and they had to write around it. Tony Soprano spends an episode in a coma, and viewers convince themselves that the rest of the series' run is actually his coma dream. A plot hole in The Mandalorian has viewers running to the internet to avow that a secondary character is actually a spy.
To be clear, none of this is harmful. And after all, I'm the one who seeks this stuff out, because I don't just watch Succession, to pick the most recent example; I read great recaps and much-less-great Reddit threads and tweets and listen to multiple podcasts about it. It's my own fault.
But it is something I'm going to stop doing, because Succession is coming to a close, and I want to experience its end in real time, without a brain a-sizzle with competing, well-argued theories. Avid fan speculation isn't a spoiler, but it does have a spoiling effect. It conjures the merely possible in a way that makes it notionally real. It creates many such possible outcomes – in so great a number and with such conviction that at least a few of them are probably gonna come close to hitting the mark. I had the endings of Better Call Saul and Watchmen and The Leftovers and many other shows "spoiled" for me in this way.
I'm curious to see how this experiment – let's call it a tactical disengagement – turns out. If it works, and I'm legitimately surprised and satisfied by the Succession finale, I might join the millions of Americans who still watch TV the way I used to as a kid – lacking content, but perfectly content.
This piece also appeared in NPR's Pop Culture Happy Hour newsletter. Sign up for the newsletter so you don't miss the next one, plus get weekly recommendations about what's making us happy.
Listen to Pop Culture Happy Hour on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
veryGood! (3)
Related
- All That You Wanted to Know About She’s All That
- Jennifer Lopez Turns Wicked Premiere Into Family Outing With 16-Year-Old Emme
- California Gov. Gavin Newsom will spend part of week in DC as he tries to Trump-proof state policies
- Cleveland Browns’ Hakeem Adeniji Shares Stillbirth of Baby Boy Days Before Due Date
- Appeals court scraps Nasdaq boardroom diversity rules in latest DEI setback
- Jennifer Lopez Turns Wicked Premiere Into Family Outing With 16-Year-Old Emme
- SNL's Chloe Fineman Says Rude Elon Musk Made Her Burst Into Tears as Show Host
- Army veteran reunites with his K9 companion, who served with him in Afghanistan
- Sam Taylor
- Indiana man is found guilty of murder in the 2017 killings of 2 teenage girls
Ranking
- The Louvre will be renovated and the 'Mona Lisa' will have her own room
- Kate Spade Outlet’s Early Black Friday Sale – Get a $259 Bag for $59 & More Epic Deals Starting at $25
- Klay Thompson returns to Golden State in NBA Cup game. How to watch
- Why California takes weeks to count votes, while states like Florida are faster
- Bodycam footage shows high
- Tampa Bay Rays' Wander Franco arrested again in Dominican Republic, according to reports
- Former NFL coach Jack Del Rio charged with operating vehicle while intoxicated
- Jury awards Abu Ghraib detainees $42 million, holds contractor responsible
Recommendation
IRS recovers $4.7 billion in back taxes and braces for cuts with Trump and GOP in power
She was found dead while hitchhiking in 1974. An arrest has finally been made.
Francesca Farago Details Health Complications That Led to Emergency C-Section of Twins
John Robinson, former USC Trojans and Los Angeles Rams coach, dies at 89
New Mexico governor seeks funding to recycle fracking water, expand preschool, treat mental health
Is Kyle Richards Finally Ready to File for Divorce From Mauricio Umansky? She Says...
Benny Blanco Reveals Selena Gomez's Rented Out Botanical Garden for Lavish Date Night
U.S.-Mexico water agreement might bring relief to parched South Texas