Current:Home > FinanceWhy the proposed TikTok ban is more about politics than privacy, according to experts -CapitalWay
Why the proposed TikTok ban is more about politics than privacy, according to experts
View
Date:2025-04-14 08:48:37
TikTok has become a dominant force in pop culture in recent years, which has prompted growing concerns from government officials over its Chinese ownership.
At least 14 states have recently banned the application from being used on government devices; some state-run public universities followed suit, banning or blocking the app on their campuses.
Last week, a bipartisan group of lawmakers, including Republican Senator Marco Rubio, announced legislation that would ban TikTok in the United States. Rubio, a member of the Senate Intelligence Committee, claimed that TikTok's Chinese parent company, Byte Dance, cannot be trusted with access to United States' user data because of the potential national security risk.
This is in part because Byte Dance is required by Chinese law to assist the government, which could include sharing user data from anywhere in the world.
"There is no more time to waste on meaningless negotiations with a CCP-puppet company," Rubio said in a statement. "It is time to ban Beijing-controlled TikTok for good."
But experts like Georgetown University law professor Anupam Chander say there isn't any concrete evidence that American TikTok users have had their data shared – or that the Chinese government is utilizing that information for political gain.
"There's no evidence of this. None of the claims here, even the insider claims that some employees make about access by people in China, that access isn't by the Chinese government, but rather others within the Byte Dance corporate structure, to [look at] data about TikTok employees and others in the United States," Chander said.
Many of the lawmakers' concerns have to do with location tracking services within the app, which they fear could be used for espionage. When it comes to social media apps, location tracking is a standard feature.
"It certainly makes sense, then, for U.S. soldiers to be told, 'Hey, don't use the app because it might share your location information with other entities," said Chander. "But that's also true of the weather app and then lots of other apps that are existing in your phone, whether they're owned by China or not."
Ryan Calo is a professor of law and information science at the University of Washington. He says that, while data privacy in the United States still needs much improvement, the proposed legislation is more about geopolitical tensions and less about TikTok specifically.
"Just in the same way that Europe is very concerned about the relationship between American companies and the American intelligence sector ... the concern that has been articulated about TikTok is that practice [of data collection], which is widespread among different kinds of digital apps, would be problematic if it turns out that there is a cozy relationship between the company TikTok and the Chinese intelligence sector," Calo said.
"The truth of the matter is, if the sophisticated Chinese intelligence sector wanted to gather information on particular state employees in the United States, it wouldn't probably have to go through TikTok."
Chander also warns against what he calls a "politicization of national security."
"It's always easy – and this happens across the world – to say that a foreign government is a threat, and 'I'm protecting you from that foreign government,' he says. "And I think we should be a little cautious about how that can be politicized in a way that far exceeds the actual threat in order to achieve political ends."
Both Chander and Calo are skeptical that an outright TikTok ban would gain much political momentum, and both argue that even if it were to move forward, banning a communication platform would raise First Amendment concerns. But Calo believes the conversation could push policy in a positive direction for Americans.
"I think that we're right in the United States to be finally thinking about the consequences of having so much commercial surveillance taking place of U.S. citizens and residents," he said. "And we should do something to address it, but not in this ad hoc posturing way, but by passing comprehensive privacy rules or laws, which is something that, for example, the Federal Trade Commission seems very interested in doing."
Edited by Mallory Yu
veryGood! (3)
Related
- Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow owns a $3 million Batmobile Tumbler
- Marsai Martin talks 'mature' style transition, child star fame and 'keeping joy'
- Hiker in Colorado found dead in wilderness after failing to return from camping trip
- Pregnant Brittany Mahomes Details Lesson Learned After Back Injury
- Could Bill Belichick, Robert Kraft reunite? Maybe in Pro Football Hall of Fame's 2026 class
- Barry Keoghan Hints at Sabrina Carpenter Relationship Status Amid Split Rumors
- NASA's Webb telescope spots 6 rogue planets: What it says about star, planet formation
- ABC’s rules for the Harris-Trump debate include muted mics when candidates aren’t speaking
- Person accused of accosting Rep. Nancy Mace at Capitol pleads not guilty to assault charge
- Errol Morris examines migrant family separation with NBC News in ‘Separated’
Ranking
- Kylie Jenner Shows Off Sweet Notes From Nieces Dream Kardashian & Chicago West
- Small plane makes emergency landing on highway, then is hit by a vehicle
- Zzzzzzz: US Open tennis players take naps before matches, especially late ones
- California advances landmark legislation to regulate large AI models
- Apple iOS 18.2: What to know about top features, including Genmoji, AI updates
- Tell Me Lies Costars Grace Van Patten and Jackson White Confirm They’re Dating IRL
- Hiker in Colorado found dead in wilderness after failing to return from camping trip
- A Pivotal Senate Race Could Make or Break Maryland’s Quest for Clean Energy Future
Recommendation
IRS recovers $4.7 billion in back taxes and braces for cuts with Trump and GOP in power
Week 1 college football predictions: Our expert picks for every Top 25 game
Man whose escape from Kansas prison was featured in book, TV movie dies behind bars
Ballot measures in 41 states give voters a say on abortion and other tough questions
Federal appeals court upholds $14.25 million fine against Exxon for pollution in Texas
Telegram CEO Pavel Durov says he had over 100 kids. The problem with anonymous sperm donation.
California lawmakers pass bill that could make undocumented immigrants eligible for home loans
Police fatally shoot man on New Hampshire-Maine bridge along I-95; child, 8, found dead in vehicle